Everyone is a critic. This cliché rings especially true on Super Bowl Sunday. Those who tune in for the big game suddenly become a head football coach, American Idol judge, entertainment guru, and advertising executive. Don’t think for a second that your esteemed blogger is any different. For the ninth time, I am back to offer my unsolicited and annoying commentary on the game action, national anthem, halftime show, and commercials. So let’s get started with my Super Bowl LIX analysis…
The Game: For the fan with no horse in the race who just wanted to see a close contest, could the game have been much worse? Even the lopsided 40-22 final score doesn’t come close to how one-sided the Eagles’ victory over the Chiefs was. Throw in plenty of penalties—many of them of the ticky-tacky variety that nullified big plays—and you can imagine that a lot was left to be desired. With the game at one point 34-0 in the second half, I think most of America was ready to take a snooze. If there was a redeeming quality, the game did feature some big pass plays that went for touchdowns but other than that this game was forgettable.

For the most part, the game itself was a snoozefest.
The Anthem: I fully understand that the game was in New Orleans and the rendition of the Star Spangled Banner possibly reflected the vibe of the city, but it wasn’t necessarily my cup of tea. I thought Jon Batiste was drowned out by his own piano and the background music. He was simply tough to hear. A lot of “extras” seemed to be going on that took away from the song. I questioned whether repeating “land of the free” three times was necessary but my thought paled in comparison to those who bet the under on the length of Batiste’s performance. With the over/under set at 120.5 seconds, the anthem ended right at the 120-second mark. If there was a fourth “land of the free” added in, there would be some pretty miffed under bettors.

Jon Batiste’s rendition of the Star Spangled Banner wasn’t my favorite (photo courtesy of Page Six).
The Commercials: In what I would consider an off-year for the Super Bowl when it came to the game/anthem/halftime show, I think the commercials provided somewhat of a bright spot. But first for the bad: I was rather repulsed by the attempts from Little Caesars and Pringles to use Eugene Levy’s eyebrows and mustaches of famous people, respectively, to generate laughs for their products. Sorry, don’t want to think of brow hair or facial hair when eating pizza or chips. Ditto to the Coffee-Mate ad with the hyperactive tongue…yuck. Also, I experienced Matthew McConaughey fatigue by the third quarter from his spots with Uber Eats and Salesforce.

Despite star power, I didn’t like the Pringles ad.
But like I said, there was also a lot to like. Kudos to the brands who incorporated their ads into the game. Rocket.com used the song “Country Roads” as the soundtrack to its impactful spot and when the FOX broadcast resumed, fans in the Superdome were singing it. I also applauded Angel Soft for purchasing the first ad of halftime and using it as a “PSA” to use the restroom. The “drink on the job” spot by Liquid Death made me Google the company, the Dunkin’ commercial that made fun of bougie coffee competitors made me laugh, and the Bud Light cul-de-sac ad made me do my best to keep up with the star power. I feel this Super Bowl also offered effective ads that advocated for women. I loved the NFL-produced ad that pushed for girls’ flag football to be a varsity sport in all 50 states and I thought the Dove ad that used “Born to Run” to warn against criticizing body types was well-done.

I thought the way the AngelSoft ad incorporated itself into the game was pretty creative.
When it came to my favorite ads from Super Bowl LIX, I have three: First, let’s start with the Google ad that promoted Gemini. It pulled at my heartstrings. Practicing for an interview by answering questions relating to the job of a dad was genius and the visuals that went with it sealed the deal for one of the best commercials of the night. The Harrison Ford ad about “freedom” was touching, clever, and even funny . The voiceover was so well-written and the background track fit it perfectly. Finally, on the lighter side, there was the Ritz ad that featured one of my favorite actresses and one of my favorite actors—Aubrey Plaza and Michael Shannon. The hilarious commercial played on the deadpan personalities of both stars and was a lot of fun…even if the spot was meant to draw attention to how Plaza and Shannon aren’t fun. I give the commercials this year a B+.

I always opt for impactful over funny, but that didn’t mean I didn’t enjoy the Ritz Super Bowl LIX commercial that just happened to have two actors I really enjoy in it.
The Halftime Show: I am an admittedly non-hip, old dad. How do I know? Well, I can give you lots of reasons but one of them is that this year’s halftime show with Kendrick Lamar did absolutely nothing for me. Although I dug some of the choreography and lighting, I was never inspired, energized, or impressed. I guess I shouldn’t have been too surprised considering I couldn’t name one Lamar song prior to tonight but I was hoping something would have grabbed my attention. To be fair, Samuel L. Jackson’s cameo and speaking parts came close, but for the most part the show was a big “miss” for me (which probably means the Super Bowl did it right).

The Kendrick Lamar halftime show failed to resonate with me (photo courtesy of Getty Images).
——–
To all those heading to work this Monday morning, I hope you have your Super Bowl recap talking points ready. Congrats, Philadelphia Eagles, on your NFL title. However, can you do me a favor? Please take a break from the Super Bowl next year…and that goes for you too, Kansas City Chiefs. Don’t Blink.
Past Super Bowl Commentary
Super Bowl LVIII
Super Bowl LVII
Super Bowl LVI
Super Bowl LV
Super Bowl LII
Super Bowl LI
Super Bowl 50
Super Bowl XLIX